Gardening in an Apartment Without a Balcony: 7 Easy Tips

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something from one of our links we may earn a commission. Thanks

Gardening in an Apartment Without a Balcony

Explore the joys of gardening in an apartment without a balcony! Learn practical tips for small spaces, discover ideal plants, and embrace the green lifestyle.

Gardening in an Apartment Without a Balcony Key Takeaways:

  • Gardening in an apartment without a balcony is entirely feasible.
  • Use vertical space, windowsills, and hanging planters for herbs, succulents, and more.
  • Optimize light with LED grow lights and choose plants that thrive indoors, like pothos or spider plants, to create a vibrant, green indoor oasis.

Think gardening in an apartment without a balcony is impossible? Think again!

This guide reveals how to transform your apartment into a lush, green haven, regardless of space constraints.

Dive into the world of indoor gardening and find out how easy and rewarding it can be to grow your own plants right in your living room!

Table of Contents

Gardening in an Apartment Without a Balcony

Are you looking to bring a little greenery into your apartment, but don’t have a balcony?

Apartment gardening is not only possible, but it also comes with a range of benefits.

From improving air quality to reducing stress and saving money, there are plenty of reasons to start your own indoor garden.

However, there are also challenges to consider, such as limited space, sunlight, and water access.

In this article, we’ll explore the types of plants you can grow in an apartment without a balcony, as well as practical tips for creating your own indoor garden.

Whether you’re a seasoned gardener or a complete beginner, there’s something here for everyone. So, let’s get started!

  • You can garden in an apartment without a balcony by utilizing vertical space and making use of windowsills.
  • Apartment gardening has many benefits, including improving air quality, reducing stress, and saving money.
  • When gardening in an apartment without a balcony, consider growing herbs, succulents, microgreens, or air plants and investing in self-watering planters.

Can You Garden in an Apartment Without a Balcony?

Indoor gardening in an apartment without a balcony is indeed possible with the right strategies and techniques.

Utilizing limited space efficiently is crucial for apartment dwellers who aspire to grow plants and vegetables indoors.

With the aid of vertical gardening systems, hanging planters, and compact containers, it’s feasible to cultivate a variety of greens, herbs, and even small fruits within the confines of a small apartment.

Incorporating grow lights and hydroponic systems can further augment the potential for a thriving indoor garden, offering a sustainable and rewarding pastime.

What Are the Benefits of Apartment Gardening?

Apartment gardening offers numerous benefits, including improved air quality, reduced stress levels, and significant cost savings for individuals.

Improves Air Quality

Apartment gardening contributes to the improvement of indoor air quality by introducing natural plant processes that filter and purify the air.

Indoor plants act as natural air purifiers, as they absorb carbon dioxide and release oxygen through photosynthesis, thereby increasing the oxygen levels indoors.

Additionally, they can remove certain air pollutants such as benzene, formaldehyde, and trichloroethylene, which are commonly found in indoor environments.

These plants also release moisture, which helps to maintain optimal humidity levels, reducing the risk of respiratory issues in occupants.

Having indoor greenery promotes cleaner, fresher air and provides a myriad of health benefits for apartment dwellers.

Reduces Stress

The presence of indoor plants and engaging in apartment gardening have been shown to reduce stress levels and promote a sense of tranquility within confined urban spaces.

Studies have indicated that tending to indoor plants can offer a therapeutic outlet for individuals facing daily stressors.

The act of caring for plants nurtures a deep connection to nature and provides a fulfilling escape from urban hustle and bustle.

The gentle rhythms of watering, pruning, and witnessing plant growth can create a calming environment that soothes the mind and uplifts overall well-being.

Apartment gardening, in particular, allows people to cultivate greenery in limited spaces, providing a fulfilling and relaxing activity that counterbalances the pressures of city living.

Saves Money

Apartment gardening presents an opportunity for individuals to save money on groceries by cultivating fresh produce at home, reducing the need for frequent store purchases.

By growing vegetables and herbs indoors, apartment dwellers can significantly cut down on their food expenses and enjoy the financial benefits of homegrown organic produce.

The initial investment in gardening supplies and seeds is minimal compared to the continuous savings from not having to purchase these items from supermarkets.

The convenience of having a readily available supply of fresh ingredients can lead to reduced food waste and overall lower grocery bills.

What Are the Challenges of Apartment Gardening?

Apartment gardening presents certain challenges, including limited space, inadequate sunlight exposure, and restricted access to water sources within urban living environments.

Limited Space

The limited space in apartments poses a significant challenge for accommodating a diverse range of plants, necessitating creative container gardening solutions and space optimization techniques.

Utilizing vertical space effectively can be a game-changer, allowing for the installation of vertical gardening systems and trellises.

Window boxes, hanging baskets, and wall-mounted planters are excellent choices for growing herbs and small vegetables.

Incorporating stackable planters and tiered shelving units maximizes space utilization, creating a visually appealing garden corner.

Mr. Stacky 5 Tier Stackable Strawberry, Herb, Flower, and Vegetable Planter - Vertical Garden Indoor/Outdoor

Limited Sunlight

The limited exposure to natural sunlight in apartments necessitates the use of alternative lighting methods such as LED grow lights to support healthy plant growth and development.

When indoor plants do not receive adequate sunlight, they may struggle to undergo photosynthesis, impacting their overall growth and appearance.

In such cases, LED grow lights prove to be a key solution to cater to the light needs of plants, providing the necessary spectrum and intensity to mimic natural sunlight.

These lights can be adjusted to different wavelengths, promoting specific growth stages such as germination, flowering, or fruiting, contributing to healthier and more vigorous plant growth.

Spider Farmer 2024 New EVO SF2000 LED Grow Light with Samsung LM301H EVO High Efficiency & Dimmable Lighting Full Spectrum Grow Light for Indoor Plants Veg Bloom Growing Lamps for 2x4/3x4 Grow Tent

Limited Water Access

The restricted access to water sources in urban apartments requires the implementation of water-efficient gardening techniques like aquaponics or hydroponics to ensure sustainable plant hydration and growth.

Apartment gardening, due to limited outdoor space, often involves indoor cultivation, which presents a distinct challenge of water availability.

Traditional watering methods may not be feasible, leading to water scarcity and potential waste.

This highlights the significance of adopting hydroponics, a system used to maximize water efficiency.

Through this integrated approach, the system recycles water, ensuring minimal wastage while providing essential nutrients to plants.

Sustainable water management is crucial for indoor gardening, as it addresses the water scarcity issue and promotes environmental conservation.

By incorporating practices like rainwater harvesting, drip irrigation, and smart watering systems, apartment gardeners can conserve water resources effectively, contributing to a more sustainable and eco-friendly urban lifestyle.

What Types of Plants Can You Grow in an Apartment Without a Balcony?

In an apartment without a balcony, individuals can cultivate a diverse array of plants, including herbs, vegetables, succulents, microgreens, and air plants, to enhance their indoor living spaces.

Herbs

Cultivating herbs in an apartment setting allows individuals to enjoy fresh culinary additions such as basil, mint, and cilantro while elevating the indoor ambiance with their aromatic presence.

REALPELATED Indoor Herb Garden Kit 10 Non-GMO Herbs- Window Herb Garden Kit with 10 Reusable Pots, Herbs, Drip Trays, Soil Discs - Window Plant Growing Kit - Kitchen Herb Garden Kit Herb Garden Gift

Indoor herb gardens provide a convenient source of flavorful and aromatic herbs, enhancing cooking experiences with a delightful burst of freshness.

The process of growing herbs within apartment spaces involves selecting the right containers, ensuring adequate sunlight and watering, and regular pruning to maintain healthy growth.

Consider the placement of herbs near windows or under grow lights, where they can receive at least 6-8 hours of sunlight daily. This promotes robust growth and ensures the development of potent flavors in the herbs.

Monitoring the soil moisture and providing proper drainage are essential aspects of nurturing indoor herb gardens, as excess water can lead to root rot.

Succulents

Costa Farms Succulents (5 Pack), Live Mini Succulent Plants, Grower's Choice Live Houseplants, Potted in Nursery Plant Pots, Potting Soil, Gift for Bulk Baby Shower, Bridal Shower, DIY Room Decor

Succulents thrive in apartment environments, offering low-maintenance beauty and diverse aesthetic appeal while adapting well to indoor conditions with minimal care requirements.

Their ability to store water in their leaves, stems, and roots makes them highly resilient to periods of neglect or irregular watering.

This is particularly beneficial for those with busy lifestyles. Succulents can be placed on windowsills, shelves, or hanging planters, infusing living spaces with a charming touch of greenery.

Variegated varieties, such as Echeveria ‘Lola’ or Haworthia ‘Zebra’, add a stunning visual interest with their unique colors and textures. They create captivating focal points within interior design schemes.

Microgreens

How To Grow Microgreens Indoors In Trays Peas Shoot Microgreens

Cultivating nutrient-rich microgreens in apartments offers a convenient and sustainable way to access fresh greens, elevating culinary experiences and nutritional intake within limited indoor spaces.

Microgreens can easily be grown indoors, even in compact living spaces. They are packed with essential nutrients like vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants, making them a valuable addition to any diet.

With just a little soil, water, and light, a variety of microgreens such as arugula, broccoli, and sunflower shoots can be cultivated.

Their rapid growth makes them perfect for apartment dwellers looking to have a steady supply of homegrown greens.

It’s a rewarding and straightforward process that can be embarked on by anyone interested in indoor gardening!

Air Plants

Ionantha Guatemala Tillandsia Air Plant, Guatemala Tillandsia Live Airplant, Healthy Arrival Guaranteed, Great Indoor Plant, Home Decor & Gift (Blue)

Air plants are well-suited for apartment living, requiring minimal maintenance and offering unique ornamental value through their ability to thrive without soil, making them an ideal indoor gardening choice.

These fascinating plants, also known as Tillandsia, have become popular among urban dwellers for their versatility and low-maintenance nature.

Their unique ability to absorb nutrients and moisture through their leaves allows them to thrive in various creative displays, such as hanging terrariums, driftwood arrangements, or even placed in stylish geometric planters.

When caring for air plants in apartments, it’s essential to provide them with bright, indirect light and soak them in water for about 20-30 minutes every week, ensuring they dry completely to prevent rot.

Air plants don’t need soil so they can be placed on a shelf or hung from the ceiling in a holder.

6PCS Hanging Air Plants Holders/Stand Mini Sea Urchin Shell Decorative Tillandsiat Succulent Air Plant Display Container for Home Office Wall Garden Beach Hawaii Theme Party Favors

With over 650 species to choose from, including the intricately patterned Tillandsia ionantha and the striking Tillandsia xerographica, these plants offer endless possibilities for enhancing the aesthetics of indoor spaces.

Growing Vegetables in Your Apartment: A Fresh Approach to Urban Gardening

How To Grow Green Beans Indoors

Have you ever dreamed of picking fresh vegetables right in your apartment? Growing vegetables in an apartment setting is not only possible, but it’s also a fun and rewarding experience.

Even without outdoor space, you can enjoy the taste of homegrown produce. Here’s how to get started on your apartment vegetable garden journey.

1. Choosing the Right Vegetables

Urban Gardening In Small Spaces: Growing spinach in pots

Selecting Suitable Varieties:
When it comes to apartment gardening, not all vegetables are created equal. Opt for varieties that thrive in limited space and require less sunlight. Think cherry tomatoes, radishes, lettuce, and baby carrots. These are perfect for smaller pots and grow well indoors.

Understanding Sunlight Needs:
Most vegetables need ample sunlight to flourish. Place your vegetable plants near a south-facing window where they’ll receive plenty of light. If natural light is limited, consider using LED grow lights to supplement.

Light Requirements For Vegetables

Here’s a table showing the light requirements for various vegetables:

Vegetable Light Requirements
Tomatoes Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Peppers Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Cucumbers Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Beans Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Peas Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Lettuce Partial Shade (3-4 hours)
Carrots Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Onions Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Radishes Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Herbs Partial Shade to Full Sun (4-6 hours)
Chard Full Sun to Partial Shade (3-6 hours)
Kale Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Arugula Full Sun to Partial Shade (3-6 hours)
Mustard Full Sun (6-8 hours)
Spinach Partial Shade (3-4 hours)
Root Vegetables Full Sun to Partial Shade (3-6 hours)

This table will help you understand the amount of sunlight each vegetable requires for optimal growth.

2. Container Gardening Basics

Selecting the Right Containers:
The key to successful container gardening is choosing the right pots. Ensure they have adequate drainage holes to prevent waterlogging. Consider the size of the mature plant; some vegetables need more room to grow.

Soil and Fertilizer Needs:
Use high-quality potting soil designed for container gardening. It’s lighter and promotes better root growth. Additionally, incorporate organic fertilizers to give your plants the nutrients they need.

3. Watering and Maintenance

Regular Watering:
Vegetables grown in containers tend to dry out faster, so regular watering is essential. However, be careful not to overwater, as this can lead to root rot.

Pest and Disease Management:
Keep an eye out for common pests and diseases. Neem oil or insecticidal soaps can help manage infestations. Regularly inspect your plants and remove any dead or diseased foliage.

4. Maximizing Space with Vertical Gardening

Utilizing Vertical Space:
If floor space is at a premium, consider vertical gardening solutions like trellises or hanging baskets. They are great for climbing plants like peas and beans.

Garden Obelisk Trellis for Climbing Plants Outdoor 6 Ft Rose Bush Round Trellis for Pots Rustproof Metal Plant Flower Trellises for Clematis Vine Jasmine Support Outdoor Indoor

5. Harvesting Your Bounty

Knowing When to Harvest:
Harvest your vegetables when they’re ripe for the best flavor. Regular harvesting often encourages more production.

Enjoy the fruits of your labor in salads, cooking, or as fresh snacks.

6. Continuous Growing and Rotating Crops

Succession Planting:
To maintain a constant supply of vegetables, practice succession planting. Once you harvest one crop, plant another. This keeps your garden productive and your plate full of fresh veggies.

Final Thoughts

Apartment vegetable gardening is a delightful and practical way to connect with nature and enjoy fresh, homegrown produce.

With a bit of creativity and care, your apartment can become a bountiful garden, providing you with fresh and nutritious vegetables all year round. Happy gardening!

How Can You Create a Garden in an Apartment Without a Balcony?

Creating a thriving garden in an apartment without a balcony involves utilizing vertical space, implementing hanging planters, maximizing windowsill areas, and investing in self-watering planter systems to optimize plant growth and visual appeal.

Utilize Vertical Space

Effectively utilizing vertical space within apartments allows for the creation of multi-tiered plant displays, optimizing the available area and enhancing the visual impact of indoor gardening setups.

Uneedem Indoor Outdoor Plant Stand, Tall 10 Tier Rack for Multiple Plants, Large Wood Holder With 11 Pots for Room, Corner, Balcony, Garden, Patio

Regarding apartment gardening, utilizing vertical space is key. This can be achieved through the use of multiple shelving units and wall-mounted planters.

These techniques not only maximize space for a variety of plants but also enhance the overall look of the living space.

Consider incorporating hanging planters and trellises to add visual interest and dimension to your indoor garden.

Use Hanging Planters

Bouqlife Hanging Planters with Macrame Plant Hangers for Indoor Outdoor Plants 3 Set Self Watering Pots Hanging Baskets Flower Pot Holders 3 Different Size

Incorporating hanging planters enables individuals to expand their indoor garden vertically, creating captivating suspended greenery while maximizing floor space and decorative potential within apartments.

With their space-saving design, hanging planters are a practical solution for those desiring a lush indoor oasis without sacrificing valuable living space.

These planters not only add visual interest to any room, but they also provide a perfect opportunity to cultivate a variety of plant varieties.

Opting for trailing or cascading plants like ivy, pothos, or spider plants in a hanging planter not only maximizes vertical space but also adds a touch of elegance.

Their versatility is further demonstrated in the ability to move them around to create a dynamic atmosphere.

Embracing the benefits of hanging planters also means acknowledging the need for proper care and attention to plant health.

Adequate watering, ensuring proper drainage and regular maintenance are essential for the well-being of the plants.

It’s important to select planters that complement the overall aesthetic of the apartment while catering to the specific needs of the chosen plants.

This includes considering factors such as planter size, material, and stability, to ensure the plants thrive in their suspended environment.

The incorporation of hanging planters adds an artistic and sustainable dimension to apartment gardening, enhancing both air quality and visual appeal.

Make Use of Windowsills

Vugosson Self Watering Planters Pots for Indoor Plants, 7 Pack 4+8+17 Inch Plastic Window Boxes Planters Herb Planter, Rectangle Rectangular Planter Windowsill Planters with Drainage and Saucer

Windowsills serve as valuable real estate for apartment gardening, accommodating a diverse array of potted plants and herbs while harnessing natural sunlight for optimal growth and vitality.

Utilizing windowsill spaces for indoor gardening can significantly enhance the ambiance of living spaces, offering a refreshing green touch and a source of fresh produce.

The strategic placement of containers near windows allows plants to soak up the abundant sunlight, promoting photosynthesis and boosting their overall health.

Windowsill gardening provides a convenient solution for individuals with limited outdoor gardening space, allowing them to cultivate their favorite plants indoors.

Invest in Self-Watering Planters

WOUSIWER 10 inch Self Watering Planters, 2 Pack Large Plastic Plant Pots with Deep Reservior and High Drainage Holes for Indoor Outdoor Plants and Flowers, White

Self-watering planters offer a convenient and efficient solution for maintaining optimal moisture levels and plant hydration within apartment gardening setups, reducing the need for frequent watering and oversight.

These innovative planters come with a built-in reservoir that allows plants to draw water as needed, promoting sustainable water management by reducing water wastage and preventing overwatering.

The self-regulating system also fosters healthier root development and minimizes the risk of water-related diseases, enhancing plant care in indoor settings.

Self-watering planters provide a practical solution for individuals with busy lifestyles or those new to gardening, as they require less frequent attention and reduce the likelihood of watering errors.

Their functionality not only saves time and effort but also contributes to the success of apartment gardening by enabling a more consistent and hassle-free approach to nurturing plants in limited space.

Embracing AeroGardens: The Future of Apartment Vegetable Gardening

Discover the wonders of using an AeroGarden for growing vegetables in your apartment!

This innovative technology revolutionizes indoor gardening, making it easier and more efficient than ever.

Perfect for small spaces, AeroGardens offers a hassle-free way to cultivate fresh veggies right in your home.

AeroGarden Harvest Elite Indoor Garden Hydroponic System with LED Grow Light and Herb Kit, Holds up to 6 Pods, Platinum

1. Understanding AeroGardens

What is an AeroGarden?
An AeroGarden is a self-contained, hydroponic indoor garden system. It automates most of the growing process, including lighting, watering, and nutrient delivery.

This system is ideal for those living in apartments without access to traditional garden space.

Benefits of Using an AeroGarden:
AeroGardens offers numerous advantages. They require no soil, thus reducing mess.

The system’s built-in LED lights simulate sunlight, essential for plant growth. Additionally, AeroGardens are compact, fitting easily on countertops or shelves.

2. Setting Up Your AeroGarden

AeroGarden Harvest Elite Indoor Garden Hydroponic System with LED Grow Light and Herb Kit, Holds up to 6 Pods, Platinum

Choosing the Right Model:
AeroGardens come in various sizes and models. Select one based on the space available in your apartment and the types of vegetables you want to grow.

Initial Setup and Planting:
Setting up your AeroGarden is straightforward. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to assemble, add water and nutrients, and insert the seed pods. Most AeroGardens come with a starter kit of seeds.

3. Maintenance and Care

Regular Monitoring:
Although AeroGardens automates much of the process, regular monitoring is crucial. Check water levels weekly and add nutrients as indicated by the system’s alerts.

Pruning and Harvesting:
Prune your plants to encourage growth. Harvest vegetables when they’re ripe for optimal taste and nutritional value.

4. Troubleshooting Common Issues

Dealing with Pests and Diseases:
Even in an AeroGarden, plants can encounter pests and diseases. Keep an eye out for signs of distress and address issues promptly using organic remedies where possible.

Managing Growth and Space:
Some plants might grow more vigorously than others. Regular pruning helps manage their growth within the confined space of the AeroGarden.

5. Enhancing Your AeroGarden Experience

AeroGarden Harvest Elite Indoor Garden Hydroponic System with LED Grow Light and Herb Kit, Holds up to 6 Pods, Platinum

Experimenting with Different Vegetables:
Try growing a variety of vegetables to see what thrives best in your AeroGarden. Leafy greens, herbs, and small root vegetables are excellent choices.

Accessorizing Your AeroGarden:
Consider additional accessories like trellises for climbing plants or extra LED grow lights for expanding your garden.

Conclusion

Using an AeroGarden for growing vegetables in an apartment is a smart, space-efficient way to indulge in gardening.

I own an AeroGarden Harvest and have been loving it for the past 2 years.

AEROGARDEN HARVEST GROWING HERBS

It’s perfect for beginners and experienced gardeners alike, offering a clean, automated, and rewarding gardening experience.

Enjoy the taste of fresh, home-grown vegetables all year round with minimal effort and maximum satisfaction!

Gardening in an Apartment Without a Balcony FAQs

Q. Can I garden in an apartment without a balcony?

A. Yes, you can still garden in an apartment without a balcony. Various indoor gardening options can work in small spaces.

Q. What are some low-maintenance plants that can thrive in an apartment without a balcony?

A. Some low-maintenance plants that can thrive in an apartment without a balcony include pothos, spider plants, and peace lilies. These plants require minimal sunlight and can be grown in small containers.

Q. Do I need a lot of space to garden in my apartment without a balcony?

A. No, you do not need a lot of space to garden in your apartment without a balcony.

You can use vertical gardening techniques, hanging plants, and small containers to maximize your space.

Hydroponic growing systems like AeroGardens are very compact and include lighting.

Q. How do I make sure my plants get enough sunlight in an apartment without a balcony?

A. You can place your plants near a window that receives ample sunlight, use artificial grow lights, or choose plants that thrive in low-light conditions.

Q. Can I grow vegetables and herbs in an apartment without a balcony?

A. Yes, you can grow vegetables and herbs in an apartment without a balcony. Some vegetables that can thrive indoors include cherry tomatoes, peppers, and herbs like basil and parsley.

Q. What are some creative ways to incorporate gardening in an apartment without a balcony?

A. You can use hanging planters, wall-mounted planters, and shelves to create a vertical garden. You can also use mason jars or recycled containers as planters. Another option is to join a community garden or utilize a shared outdoor space, if available.

Concluding Thoughts on Growing Vegetables in an Apartment

As we wrap up our exploration of growing vegetables in an apartment, it’s clear that limited space doesn’t have to limit your gardening dreams.

With the right approaches and tools, you can enjoy fresh, homegrown produce right in your cozy apartment. Let’s recap the key takeaways and some final tips.

1. Celebrating Small Space Successes

Embracing Your Achievements:
Celebrate the victories of your apartment gardening journey, no matter how small. Whether it’s your first ripe tomato or a flourishing herb garden, each success is a step towards a greener, healthier lifestyle.

Sharing Your Experience:
Share your gardening stories and tips with friends or on social media. Your experience can inspire and encourage others to start their own apartment gardening adventures.

2. Continuing Your Gardening Journey

Expanding Your Knowledge:
Continuously educate yourself about different plants and gardening techniques. The more you learn, the more diverse and productive your garden will become.

Experimenting with New Plants:
Don’t be afraid to try growing different vegetables or experimenting with new gardening methods. Each season can be an opportunity to explore new varieties and techniques.

3. Sustainable Practices and Eco-Friendly Gardening

Adopting Sustainable Methods:
Incorporate sustainable practices into your gardening, like using organic fertilizers and conserving water. These practices not only benefit your plants but also contribute to a healthier environment.

Recycling and Composting:
Consider starting a small compost bin for kitchen scraps. This can be a great way to recycle organic waste and provide rich nutrients for your plants.

4. Reflecting on the Health and Wellness Benefits

Enjoying the Harvest:
Remember to enjoy the fruits (and vegetables!) of your labor. Homegrown produce is not only fresher but often more nutritious and flavorful than store-bought alternatives.

Mindfulness and Stress Relief:
Gardening is a wonderful way to relax and de-stress. Taking care of your plants can provide a peaceful break from the hustle and bustle of daily life.

Final Thoughts

Growing vegetables in an apartment is more than just a hobby; it’s a sustainable, fulfilling way to connect with nature and enhance your well-being.

It teaches patience, care, and creativity, all while providing the joy of harvesting your own food.

So, keep nurturing your green thumb and enjoy every step of this rewarding journey! Happy Apartment Gardening!

Leave a Comment